Skip to Navigation Skip to Content
Decorative woodsy background

Giant Silk Moths – Survival of the Fattest

Luna_web.jpg
Illustration by Adelaide Tyrol

Many years ago, a friend and fellow naturalist encouraged me to raise cecropia moths as a way of increasing the local population, which had become scarce around my home in southern Connecticut. The decline of the cecropia moth – one of the largest of our native giant silk moths – was linked, ironically, to biological controls that humans were using to kill gypsy moths, exotic moths that were introduced to the U.S. by commercial silk producers. One June afternoon, my friend showed up with a small twig from a black cherry tree. On the underside of one of the leaves were 12 tiny eggs, which, about a week later, hatched into small, black fuzzy caterpillars, no bigger than a grain of rice. My job was to keep them supplied with fresh black cherry leaves.

Within a few weeks, the caterpillars (eating and pooping machines, really) were now green with yellow and blue knobs, and – having grown exponentially – were about the size of my index finger. I marveled at their consumption rate, as the cherry leaves needed replenishing two or three times a day now, even though only four or five caterpillars remained. Finally, with only the three largest caterpillars surviving, they pupated into robust, fuzzy cocoons, prompting me to wonder if Darwin had it slightly wrong: survival of the fattest might have been more accurate.

There are about 20 species of giant silk moths in North America, but only four species occur in Vermont and New Hampshire. As adults, these are impressive moths indeed. Not only are they enormous – cecropia and polyphemus moths can be as large as your hand – they are also beautiful to look at, with intricate patterns, rich colors, and striking eyespots. Perhaps the best-known Saturniinae is the dramatic, lime-green luna moth, with its purple-edged wings, four transparent eyespots, and long curving tails, reminiscent of a barn swallow.

After overwintering in their silken cocoons, adult silk moths typically emerge in June or July. So, beginning in late-May, I checked my three pupae each morning for signs of metamorphosis. Finally, one morning I was rewarded with two fresh moths (both females), their pristine wings completely engorged and dry, while the third (a male) was just beginning to “pump up” its wings. For a cecropia moth “farmer,” this is when the fun begins.

If giant silk moth caterpillars are eating and pooping machines, adults are breeding machines. Having only rudimentary mouth parts, they don’t feed at all during their short lives, but instead devote all their energy toward locating a mate and reproducing (with only a week or so to live, there’s no time to waste). So that evening, I took the newly emerged female moths (identified by their small antennae), placed them in a crudely-made wire mesh cage about the size of a microwave oven, and hung it from a cherry tree as a lure. I was fishing for wild cecropias. Meanwhile, the male (identified by his large, feathery antenna) would have to wait before being released.

After emergence, female giant silk moths remain physically inactive, conserving their limited fat reserves while minimizing exposure to predators. Nevertheless, they communicate chemically with males, letting them know where they are. Using a gland on the tip of their abdomen, females release a plume of pheromones into the evening air. This “perfume” is detected by the males’ highly branched, feathery antennae which contain tiny, hair-like structures called sensilla. Receptor cells on the sensilla bind with the pheromone molecules, stimulating the males to relentlessly follow the scent trail. Although the distance from which males can detect the pheromone is still unknown, marked individuals have been recovered up to 20 miles away in just a few days.

After just one night of hanging in the cherry tree, I was surprised to find a male cecropia on the outside of the cage the following morning. His wings were pale and tattered, evidence of his efforts to locate a female, with which he was now abdomen-to-abdomen through the wire mesh. Another tattered male was present the following day after I had released the captive male (so he could join the breeding population that was evidently in the area). The two captive females laid dozens of eggs each, only to die shortly thereafter, having accomplished their sole purpose in life.

I continued to raise cecropia moths for a couple years, releasing maybe a dozen individuals to the surrounding area. Whether or not I was actually helping out the local population was unclear, but since my female “lures” never had any trouble attracting wild male moths, I eventually decided that, in the grand scheme of things, I was probably having very little impact. Despite my good intentions, it appeared that survival of the fittest (or fattest) was working quite well without my help.

Discussion *

Aug 26, 2022

I recently found 2 cecropia caterpillars on a rhododendron which no one cites as a host plant.  They seem quite content there and are well filled out, ready to spin a coccoon.  Should I leave them there over the winter or move them to a more sheltered spot?

Ann McKenzie
Jul 20, 2015

This morning, a large silkworm moth was struggling to survive in a pet water dish.  I scooped it out and showed it to my husband.  He had been in a hurry to get to the office but this moth made him whip out his camera and take photos from all angles.  It is one of the most beautiful bugs I’ve ever seen and I’ve seen a lot of beautiful bugs in amazing places.  Your post helped me identify it and I’d like to think that one of your moths made it to my home in Fairfield County.

Natalie
Sep 03, 2012

  Think we just saw a lunar moth caterpillar over in crawford notch on the 29th of August by the waterfall.Some woman was taking video of it. Was at least 3-4 inches long.Found this site cause was looking it up and the first thought that came into my head was Lunar moth caterpillar.Quite a few years ago saw an adult in my yard and it was gorgeous.Didn’t think there were cherry trees in the Notch though.I thought they would have already done their thing by the fall but didn’t know that they overwintered up here.

Carol Collins
Jun 28, 2012

It is rewarding to rear, mate and release cecropia, or any of our other Saturniid moths, but don’t be lulled into a false sense of silken security.  The Compsilura concinnata, which is the tachinid fly you alluded to introduced in 1906 by the USDA (in some areas released as recently as 1986), still takes quite a toll on our native Saturniid moths.  In 2009, I did a local study using Antheraea polyphemus caterpillars and approximately 90% of those recovered had been hit by Compsilura.  Odd as it may seem I was always a bit relieved to see external eggs knowing they were most likely of a native fly parasitoid (such as those Peter mentioned/showed in his comment.  Lucky for his very cooperative patient, these were removed before hatching and having a chance to burrow).  What I did know, they had not been left by the exotic gypsy hunter, which directly deposits larvae (as do our native wasp predators).  In the case of Compsilura, the life cycle is then quite short and the demise of its host can be as little as 5-7 days.  C. concinnata has 3 to 4 generations, gypsy moth only one, thus the need for future hosts throughout the season.  The many weeks of feeding and large size make many of our native wild silk moth larvae an easy target for this fly.

Since a very small percentage of the hundreds of eggs deposited by each moth survive to the adult stage in nature (not only due to other insect predators), it is likely that the dozen or so you released made some, no matter how small, difference.  I rear and release a number of species every year (this is my 14th) and figure for every pair of mating moths that continue to produce one more pair my local population gets a helping hand.

If interested, I just updated images from this study: http://www.flickr.com/photos/54787179@N00/sets/72157627565358450/

Bonnie Caruthers
Jun 01, 2012

Peter, great photos, thanks for sharing!  I love the head-on close-up of the caterpillar.  Looks like your moth was a male.  If you ever need a new career, you might find work as a caterpillar surgeon!

Steve Faccio
May 30, 2012

A couple years ago we found a cecropia caterpillar in an apple tree over our driveway.  It had little white dots on it that I figured must be tachinid eggs.  I took them off with a needle, but the next day they reappeared.  We finally wrapped the branch in netting to keep the flies off.  The caterpillar pupated, over-wintered over the driveway, and emerged the next spring.  There are some photos at http://www.pbase.com/plbh/cecropia_moth

Peter Hollinger

Leave a reply

To ensure a respectful dialogue, please refrain from posting content that is unlawful, harassing, discriminatory, libelous, obscene, or inflammatory. Northern Woodlands assumes no responsibility or liability arising from forum postings and reserves the right to edit all postings. Thanks for joining the discussion.